Homemade Buttermilk Syrup is a thick and creamy topping that’s perfect for drizzling over waffles, pancakes or ice cream!
This delicious syrup also makes a tasty homemade gift.
Homemade Buttermilk Syrup is a recipe that’s been around for ages. I think I was first introduced to this deliciousness through my sister in law, Rebecca.
She would always make homemade treats for everyone for Christmas, and one year she gifted us a jar of this liquid gold. It’s life changing guys.
The trick with this super easy homemade buttermilk syrup is to not over cook it.
You can go from sweet and delicious to bitter and gross if you burn the sugar. Just make sure you keep stirring and keep an eye on the mixture while it boils.
We love to serve the buttermilk syrup over hot pancakes, like these Strawberry Greek Yogurt Pancakes. One of our favorite ways to use the syrup though is on top of vanilla ice cream.
The syrup thickens over the cold ice cream and it’s almost like a chewy caramel. Try adding a few chopped pecans on top for an extra special sundae!
We reserve this deliciousness for special occasions, but it’s really good any time of the year. It lasts for weeks in the fridge, so it’s great to make a batch to have on hand when the craving hits.
You’re going to love this creamy and sweet syrup!
HELPFUL PRODUCTS TO MAKE THIS RECIPE:
Make sure you don’t miss a thing! Follow I Wash You Dry here:
FACEBOOK | PINTEREST | TWITTER | INSTAGRAM | BLOGLOVIN
Homemade Buttermilk Syrup
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup butter
- 1 cup sugar
- 1/2 cup buttermilk
- 1 tablespoon Light Karo Syrup
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Instructions
- Combine the butter, sugar, buttermilk, and Karo syrup in a pot and bring to a boil for 2-3 minutes, stirring frequently.
- Add the baking soda and vanilla and stir till combined. The color of the syrup will turn to a light golden brown. Remove from the heat and continue to stir till the syrup thickens. Let it cool and serve immediately, or store in fridge in an air tight container. (you can warm it up in the microwave)
Notes
Nutrition
Originally published on 5/10/2012. Updated with new photos on 7/18/2017.
PIN THIS IMAGE TO SAVE THE RECIPE:
I can’t wait to try this. I have never heard of Buttermilk syrup before! Thanks for in intrigue!!
We make our own maple syrup from our maple trees and use it on anything we can. We even use it in our coffee and I like it better than the bees honey I used. After reading some of the comments here, I am considering trying this recipe. Sometimes all it takes to change a person’s mind are a few positive comments.
Hi! Could this be made with reconstituted dry buttermilk mix? Sounds so dreamy & delicious!
I haven’t tried the recipe with reconstituted buttermilk so I’m not too sure how the outcome would taste.
How long can you store this in the fridge please ? Sounds like an awesome Christmas gift. Thank you.
How long is this good for in the freezer?
Hi, this looks like a wonderful addition to the Breakfast pancakes.
I was wondering if it could be put in jars and processed so it will keep longer?
It would make ideal Christmas gifts.
Despite what is found on the internet, there are no science-based methods for home canning of cheeses, milk, butter or other dairy products. Clemson Extension and the National Center for Home Food Preservation do not recommend any process for canning these products. However, it can safely be frozen
Thanks for the information!
You are welcome. I am happy I could be of some help. 🙂 Enjoy the syrup, it is divine
Thanks for your tips Darlene!
I just made 1 batch to try in case it wasn’t as good as you said. I just made 5 more batches!!! AMAZING is all I can say!
HA! So glad you enjoyed it Debra!
This is the BEST syrup EVER. Perfect amount of sweetness and did I mention it only takes a few minutes to make? This syrup is liquid gold. 🙂
Yes!!! I too have referred to it as liquid gold a time or two. 😉
Sounds great!
How much does it make?
And can it be put in a hot-water bath canner, so it will be able to be stored on a shelf, instead of fridge?
This is the best syrup ever. But I’m also wondering if anyone has figured out a way to can and store in the pantry?
So glad you enjoyed the recipe Angie!
It sounds and looks delicious, I can’t wait to try it but what is Karo syrup and can it be substitute by something else?
This looks amazing but one quick question before I run off to the kitchen, could this be sealed in jars and given as gifts it looks amazing
Do you suppose you could can this safely?
Wow, thanks for sharing this home-made syrup. This recipe looks simple enough.
Sounds delish but is there a substitute for the karo syrup?
Kari is 100% glucose syrup made from corn which is different from high fructose corn syrup. When called for in recipes except candy making, you can substitute agave nectar in a 1:1 ratio and get the same result. Great recipe no matter which one you use. Thanks Shawn!
I've made a really similar syrup, and it is seriously DIVINE. The best. Amazing. It's a diet-killer in a pot!! And I loved your thoughts about motherhood! I don't think I ever had a bedtime story end in the child falling asleep!!
That's what I'm planning on! Fingers crossed!! Happy mothers day to you too!
I have a quart sized mason jar full in my fridge! It's great on ice cream too!
Oh yes… this is right there with caramel. It's delish!
Please do!
Happy Mother's Day! I love pancakes…and could definitely go for a stack smothered in this syrup tomorrow morning 🙂 Yum
Your list made me laugh out loud! It's so true, every word! Buttermilk syrup is one of my favorites. Maybe I should make a batch before Sunday. 😉
My recent post Chocolate Covered Strawberry Bites
gorgeous! You are really close to making caramel sauce and that is a beautiful thing…this looks so good!
My recent post Steamed Brussels’s Sprouts and Broccoli with Cheezy Coconut Sauce
Oh my goodness….that sounds amazing! I'm going to have to try this.
My recent post White Chocolate Covered Long Stem Strawberries
Ah yes, there is always some sort of surprise ingredient to be found in kid-made pancakes, which makes them even more special on Mother's Day. Cute post, Shawn and Happy Mother's Day to you!
My recent post Mother’s Day Recipes: Breakfast, Lunch, Beverages & Desserts
This is so great…I have never even thought about making my own syrup. IT looks so caramely and amazing!
Thanks Dara! Right back at ya!
Yes! This waaaay better than maple or blueberry…bring a straw!
SO TRUE!
The syrup looks and sounds fantastic. Bookmarked!
My recent post Cilantro-Lime Marinated Flank Steak
These pancakes look amazing. I hope you're looking the other way because I'm salivating all over the computer screen 🙂
My recent post Sandwich Bites with Sweet Mustard Sauce & Blog Love, Part 2
What a treat. Iam a bit tired of maple and blueberry syrups. Now I have a new one I can try. I hope you have a great day. Blessings…Mary
I just LOVE you blog, Shawn!! Unfortunately, I'm always hungry when I read it 😉 So excited you got to go away for a few days for the blog camp 🙂 what a treat!! 😉
My recent post back on the bandwagon…
It's a staple in our fridge…just sayin!
Thanks Gerry!
Fantastic looking pancakes and syrup!! Your right, I can just hear the words.."Oh pancakes, they're…..umm lovely ,mmm" LOL.
Happy Mothers Day when it rolls around!
Feel free to come back and drool anytime! It's natural!
Thanks diane! Hope you have a great mothers day too!!
Oh thanks Ali! Your blog is so great too! It initially inspired me to do my own! Your great!
looks delicious! Hope you have a WONDERFUL Mother's Day!
Yeah the laundry and dishes never ends. I could have a pancake with this syrup to brighten up.