How To Make Homemade Rolls

When it comes to family gatherings that involve a rather large bird to be cooked, I am always looking forward to one thing.

Homemade Rolls.

pinterest

Light & fluffy, soft & warm and most definitely slathered with butter.

There is just something about the thought of biting into a homemade roll that makes me all giddy. Then if you’re lucky and there are leftover rolls, you get to make things like mini turkey or ham sandwiches, or slather some more butter on and drizzle a little honey.

Pure. Bliss.

This is a recipe that has been floating around my husband’s side of the family for years, and it’s not even their recipe! They call them Bundy Rolls, named after Mrs. Bundy {of course} . 

While I’m not a huge fan of using yeast cause it generally takes too long {I’m kinda impatient}, these are well worth the wait.

If you have a stand mixer with a dough hook attachment that’s perfect.

You could also prepare and knead the dough in a bread machine.

If you’re extremely adventurous you could knead the dough by hand {or just hand this recipe to someone else in the family with a mixer and enjoy the fruits of their labor}.

How To Make Homemade Rolls:

Start off by pouring warm water (run your tap on hot) into the bowl of your stand mixer or bread machine.

Add some honey (for sweetness) and salt (for saltness) huh?

Then you’re going to add some yeast.

I plan on making these at least 462 times this winter so I bought a jar of yeast. Word.

Once the yeast is in the warm bath, it’s going to get all friendly and start foaming on the surface.

Give it about 5 minutes to start reacting then you’re free to add the butter flavor crisco, and one cup of flour at a time.

That butter flavor crisco is awesome. It may be a little chunky at first but once the dough starts to take shape it gets pulled and blended into the dough perfectly.

Keep adding little amounts of flour until the dough starts picking up bits of dough off the sides of the bowl and you’re able to pinch the dough and don’t come away with goopy fingers.

My hands were previously goopy from testing the dough before this picture, but I assure you, those fingers are clean.

A little chubby…and man hand-ish… but clean none the less.

Let your machine/mixer knead the dough for about 15 minutes. You can include the time it took to make the dough not goopy. I wont tell on you.

Once that’s done, take a clean towel and cover your mixing bowl (or leave it in the bread machine).

Leave it in a warm place and then attempt to unload the dishwasher with a 1 year old.

It’s like dishwasher tango.

For every dish you put away, she runs away with another.

Then quietly follow her to her secret hiding spot where she has sneakily stashed all your whisks.

After an hour of this nonsense, get back to your bowl of dough.

It should be double the size it was before.

Punch it down and then pull off  large golf ball sized bits of dough and line them up in pretty rows on a baking sheet.

Then cover them again.

Yes, I said again.

It’s important to let the rolls rise two times. It helps give them the fluffy, irresistible texture on the inside.

Cover them with the same clean towel and go attempt to fold laundry with a 1 year old.

It’s called laundry tango.

After another hour of trying to keep piles of underwear from being stolen your rolls should look like this…

Glorious.

Now all that’s left is to bake them!

As soon as they pop out of the oven brush the tops with butter.

I just grab a stick from the fridge and start rubbing my buns.

Er… rolls… uh…with the butter…

You get the idea.

The tops of the rolls have a delightfully thin crust while the inside is still soft and fluffy thanks to the double rise we did.

Totes worth it.

Nothing left to do but crack it open and add some more butter.

You deserve it.

You had to play dishwasher tango.

Yup, so worth it.

I sure hope you’ll give these a try!

Make sure you don’t miss a thing! Follow I Wash You Dry here:
FACEBOOK | PINTEREST | GOOGLE+ | TWITTER | INSTAGRAM | BLOGLOVIN

Print

How To Make Homemade Rolls

The absolute best homemade rolls!

  • Author: Shawn
  • Prep Time: 2 hours
  • Cook Time: 20 minutes
  • Total Time: 2 hours 20 minutes
  • Yield: 36 1x
  • Category: Side dish
  • Method: Baked
  • Cuisine: American
Scale

Ingredients

  • 2 3/4 cups warm water (run hot water out of your tap)
  • 1/4 cup honey
  • 3/4 tsp salt
  • 1/4 cup Butter Flavor Crisco
  • 1 1/2 tsp yeast
  • 7 cups flour + more if needed
  • butter for brushing on top of rolls

Instructions

  1. In the bowl of your stand mixer (fitted with your dough hook) add warm water, honey, salt and yeast. Stir it gently and let it sit for 5 minutes till the yeast activates and gets foamy.
  2. Add the Crisco and one cup of flour at a time and mix until dough starts to form. Keep adding flour until the dough starts to pick up dough off the sides of the bowl and is not sticky when touched with your finger. Let your machine knead the dough for 15 minutes total.
  3. Once it’s done kneading cover the bowl with a clean cloth towel and place in a warm spot (by a window or on top of the oven works) and let the dough rise for 1 hour.
  4. After an hour punch down the dough and divide the dough into large golf ball size balls. Arrange about an inch apart on a baking sheet or casserole dish. Cover again with towel and leave in a warm place to rise for another hour.
  5. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
  6. Once the rolls have risen for the second time, place them in the oven and bake for 20 minutes.
  7. Remove them from oven and immediately brush butter on the tops of the rolls.
  8. Take a huge bite of a roll and try to blow/chew at the same time cause the rolls are still too hot.
  9. Let cool slightly and then try again.
  10. Enjoy.

Keywords: homemade, rolls

About the author

Shawn is the Owner and Creator of I Wash You Dry. She loves to create and share simple, family-friendly recipes. Mom to 5 adorable children and dwells in the desert of Southern Utah.
59 Responses
  1. Janet Burton

    Hi,
    Would like to try making these rolls for Thanksgiving dinner.
    At what point can I stop and finish thanksgiving day?
    Thanks so much!

  2. Hey Shawn, What size sheet pan did you use, and how many dough balls did you put on each? (I’d like to know these so that I’d also get the wonderful pull-apart rolls :)) – Thanks!

    1. Hi Linda! I used a half sheet pan (18″x13″) to make 2 dozen rolls (4 rolls by 6 rolls), then for the last dozen I put them in a 9″x13″ pan (3 rolls by 4 rolls). The ones in the 9×13 were closer together which resulted in them being more of the pull apart kind. Hope that helps! 🙂

      1. Thanks Shawn! I think these rolls will make my boyfriend and his family very happy at Thanksgiving! Normally, I make potato rolls, but this year it’ll be different. I will just have to enjoy making them, watching them rise, salivate at the smell emanating from the oven whilst they are baking, and seeing the family devour them because I can’t eat gluten – boohoo. Thanks again, great blog you have here!

        1. Hi Shawn again. I bake breads pretty often, and noticed that the amount of yeast is only 1 1/2 teaspoons. Is this correct, or should it be 1 1/2 tablespoons? Thanks.

  3. Jennifer

    I would like to bake these right before I serve my thanksgiving dinner. I d like to make the dough the day before. Would I let it rise just once before refrigerateing? Then pull out and let in get to room temp and allow to rise again? (And can I make dough balls on baking sheet straight from the fridge for the second rise?) MY first thanksgiving dinner, and I want to wow my family with homemade warm rolls:)

  4. Beth

    The rolls looked mouth-watering so I attempted them today. I followed the recipe exactly and I let them sit by the window for 1 hour covered. The dough rose, however, it was very sticky and not formed at all. I added two more cups of flour, it seem to be a little less sticky. As of this moment they are sitting in my mixer with the cloth still on top. How long can I keep the dough like this? A few hours or even over night? I live in New Jersey and it’s quite cool now, no humidity. Do you think next time instead of adding the 7 cups of flour as the recipe says, should I add 9 or even 10 cups? Thank you Shawn!

    1. Hi Beth, first- if you want to leave the dough overnight, I would seal it up and place it in the fridge. Before baking you’ll want to bring it back to room temperature and let it rise again. Second- I would start off with the smaller amount of flour and keep adding a little more until the dough comes away clean from the sides of your mixer. You can always add more flour, but you can’t take it away, know what I mean? Hope that helps!

  5. Hillary Rossi

    I was so excited about this recipe! Pinned it awhile back and decided to make these rolls to go with a nice beef stew….
    Not sure WHAT happened, but these ‘rolls’ came out like rock hard biscuits! =(
    I make bread biscuits etc ALL THE TIME, so this recipe did not strike me as different or difficult in any way….
    Really not sure how they turned out so absolutely awful……..

    1. Hi Hillary, I’m sorry these rolls didn’t turn out for you. Sounds like maybe your yeast didn’t work. Did you proof the yeast? Did you let the rolls rise twice? They always turn out fabulous for me, so I would suggest giving it a second try and make sure you have some active yeast. 🙂

      1. SkippyMom

        I have baked yeast breads and rolls for years and I have no idea how 1 1/2 tsp of yeast to 7 cups of flour would get that about of dough to raise to any appreciable height. Is that a typo per chance?

        These are my family’s favorite too, but I noticed you mentioned pizza rolls [on pinterest is where I saw i] never realizing I can use my recipe for Grandma’s rolls [that’s what we call them :)] for that. I do llke the idea of butter flavored Crisco – thanks for the hint.

        And my family and I were laughing [in empathy] at the Dishwasher Tango. Too funny.

    1. Hi Traci, if you’re going to freeze the dough, I would do it after the first rise. Get all the dough balls formed and freeze them individually. Then when you’re ready to bake them pull them out and leave them in a warm place with a clean towel covering them. Let them rise and then bake. If you just want to freeze the baked rolls, I would wait till they have come to room temperature before placing them in a zipclose bag and placing them in a freezer. Pull them out and let come to room temperature, you can place them in a microwave safe bowl and cover them with a towel and warm them up for 30 seconds per batch to get them nice and warm again. I hope that answered your question! 🙂

      1. Marie

        I’m going to hijack this post to say thanks! I had the same doubt – I like to make my own bread, but since I live alone it always ends up going bad before I can eat all of it, which is just such a shame!

Leave a Reply

Shawn Syphus Hi, I'm Shawn and I'm a busy mom of five; pretending to live on a budget. I love to cook, and explore new recipes, but they have to be quick and easy with as few dishes as possible.

I Wash You Dry Newsletter

Popular Categories