Debbie January 5, 2020 at 5:17 pm Reply Mine turned out VERY firm, almost like dough. Don’t know what I did wrong, even added a touch more vanilla/peppermint & melted chocolate. Unfortunately I had to use white chocolate chips (Hershey). Could that have been the problem, even though they melted smoothly (a lot of stirring)? Didn’t use sprinkles, didn’t want anyone to think they were leftovers.